Wednesday 19 December, 2018

House Speaker rules: No contempt in alleged intimidation incident

House Speaker Brigid Anisette-George has ruled that there was no breach of privilege in an alleged incident which occurred at the Parliament tea room last Friday between Arima MP Anthony Garcia and Couva South MP Rudranath Indarsingh.

Indarsingh claimed that he was cursed at and threatened by Garcia – allegations the Arima MP denies.

The Couva South MP wrote to the House Speaker over the alleged incident, describing it as one of intimidation and seeking to have it referred to the Privileges Committee.

Anisette-George, however, felt otherwise.

In delivering her ruling, she stated that there must be established that there was an accompanying threat to do something for there to be a finding of contempt on the ground of intimidation, as per Parliamentary procedure.

But, she felt that this stipulation was not met.

“The matter seeks to have referred to the Committee of Privileges, for consideration and report, a certain statement made to him, allegedly with a degree of vigour and colour by the Member for Arima in the members’ dining room on March 9, 2018.

The member for Couva South claims that the words of the Member for Arima constituted an act of intimidation designed to deter him from fulfilling his duties as a member of this House.”

“I have read the submission of the Member for Couva South and the accompanying attachments. I have also noted the reports on this incident that have been published in the media.

I have certainly considered this matter and I have also carefully reviewed the relevant literature on cases like this. Further…I have taken particular note of the fact that the Member for Couva South admitted in his submission that he responded to the Member for Arima in appropriate fashion, so as to protect himself.”

“In the circumstances, I find no prima facie case of breach of privilege in this matter, and I so rule,” Anisette-George concluded.

 

Get the latest local and international news straight to your mobile phone for free:

Download the Loop News Caribbean app on Google Play Store: http://bit.ly/GetALoop

Download the Loop News Caribbean app on the App Store: http://bit.ly/GetiLoop

Get the latest local and international news straight to your mobile phone for free: